Update9: The beautiful, young and a bit naïve face of the Moldovan “Orphans’ Revolution”

Update: Police is reportedly blocking the classes at universities and schools where students are prohibiting them to join the protests. There are also unconfirmed reports that authorities are gathering crowds to stage an “counter-revolution”. During the night police is believed to have arrested over 200 young protesters. Still many of them went again to the square in front of the Government to continue expressing their disagreement with the elections results.

THE ORPHANS’ REVOLUTION

Now, after having expressed my concerns over the violent clashes yesterday, I would like to make myself clear on how I see the last two days’ events. This is very important, since the ruling Communist party media resources assisted by the Russian media are offering a distorted and completely out-of-the-reality picture. The protests in Chisinau have started because young students were unhappy with the elections stolen by the Communist Party. They have organized themselves through blogs, and social networks like Facebook and Odnoklassniki.ru. By the way, the administration of Odnoklassniki.ru, a Russian social networking site, has reportedly shut down the discussion group that mobilized Moldovan youths.

Students wanted to organize just a simple flash-mob, lighting candles on the Great National Assembly Square as if “mourning the Communist Moldova”. The initial group did not think about a protest rally, or any big demonstration. However, they were joined by thousands of other young people, who felt and though similar. Their slogans were “Freedom!”, “I fight, I resist, I am anti-communist!”, “We want another voting!”, and so on.

Authorities have ignored young people, which were united by the noble idea to defend their rights and their disagreement to accept the lies bought by everyone else (their parents, the public functionaries, other people feeding on the Communist cronyism, international observers and officials). Because they have seen it with their own eyes, they have seen how useless was ODIHR this time in identifying frauds. The elections were stolen in a sense, that even before observer came to the country, using mass media under control and administrative resources the ruling Communist party has intimidated, bought, forced, convinced people to vote for them, installing mechanisms to control that process. During the elections there are many accusations that dead people were on the list, that mentally handicapped people were forced to vote, and so on. In a country where only ~1.4 mln. people voted, tens of thousand of votes mean a lot! Even 1% may be important, giving the PCRM the ability to get the constitutional majority. As an ODIHR former elections observer myself I am so disappointed and as a researcher I insist that that organization is not able with its stone-age election observation methodology to catch the very sophisticated tricks elaborated by post-Soviet authoritarian countries specifically to fool ODIHR. That organization should review its observation methods because it is transforming into a body that legitimize the development of authoritarianism in post soviet countries. A RECOUNT OF VOTES IS NOT NEEDED, WE NEED ANOTHER ROUND OF ELECTINOS, WHERE ALL PARTIES HAVE EQUAL ACCESS TO MEDIA, AND ADMINISTRATIVE RESOURCES WILL NOT BE USED!

I am deeply disappointed by the reaction of the Western governments, shame on you, as you’ve been defended by the United States for tens of years, so that Soviet Union does not conquer you and “convince” you to join the Warsaw Pact, therefore today you have the duty to pay your debt of freedom. I have been told by some Moldovan that a Danish acquaintance stated – we don’t need you. I wish United States would have told you that after the Second World War, as they have spent so much money to rebuild you and keep you free. THAT IS WHY YOUNG MOLDOVAN STUDENTS GOT INTO THE SQUARE! – because nobody cared.

Now the communists and their Eastern “partners” are building a huge media myth to discredit the pure ideals of Moldovan youth willing nothing more than freedom and respect for their rights. Their protests were labeled the “Orphans’ Revolution” because under the Communist government close to a third of Moldovan citizens (their parents) went abroad to earn money for a living.

That is another face of Moldovan protests, where kids got into streets because their parents betrayed them and their European dream proved to be a fake, because “EUROPE DOES NOT NEED MOLDOVA”. IF YOU DON’T NEED US, WE WILL COME TO YOU, EITHER FREE AND AS MEMBERS OF EUROPEAN FAMILY, OR AS DISAPPOINTED AND ANGRY AS RUSSIAN SOLDIERS IN SOME 20-50 YEARS. BEWARE EUROPE, DO NOT BE INDIFFERENT!!!!

14 Responses to “Update9: The beautiful, young and a bit naïve face of the Moldovan “Orphans’ Revolution””

  1. bogdan Says:

    miting de solidaritate in piata universitatii http://sp2.ro/a5f3e6 .!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. Vlad Says:

    I can see Europe panicking by the idea of Moldavians at the gate. Oh, we are so terrifying, so dangerous, we even can steal computers under EU flag!
    Don’t be silly – there was always backwater provinces and god-forgotten places. Unfortunately, Moldova doesn’t have any resources neither it is located on a major trade route (the only trade route is Balkans-Russia and none of those two regions are “old EU”). It even doesn’t lie close enough to Middle East like Georgia or Azerbaijan or has a big diaspora like Armenia. It just plainly doesn’t have anything that it can offer to Brussels or Washington. So they are obviously not very much interested, no matter how insulting this may sound for us.

    As for orphans betrayed by parents, somehow those poor orphans take pictures with modern phones. Very far from Dickensian pictures of poor abused orphans. I’m not sure that looters have the beautiful face – most of them are “gopniki”. Well, the world saw similar protests in 1992 in Rodney King riots in LA – poor orphans of single mothers, left by their fathers, blah-blah-blah. Somehow some of such orphans tidy themselves up and become… hey, Barack Obama, for example. Sometimes, they loot. Poor, beautiful, young and a bit naive criminals.

    Vlad (Chisinau-Boston)

  3. Dumitru Minzarari Says:

    Don’t be silly Vlad – Moldova was once a part of Soviet Union, and Moldovans have fought the NATO countries around the globe, in different proxy wars, as part of the USSR military. The Russian MFA stated on its web-site, that “the elections results are in the interest of the Moldovan and Russian people”… which is so telling. If you obviously can see my hint, and even understand it.

    Further, having “fancy” phones do not make you rich – you know the Moldovan culture, if you lived in Chisinau. Besides, even if they are not poor, these youngsters are protesting for what they see as fraudulent elections. Do you accuse them for that small?

    And about the looting, don’t be naive – inform yourself well, and try to be distant in your judgment. You may also read few other posts on this blog in ENglish, that provide some walk-through the protests, looting, reasons behind it, of course, the way I see it.

  4. Dumitru Minzarari Says:

    Besides, don’t forget, the EU has positively assessed the elections, which even some OSCE observers recognized they had “very strong feeling there was manipulation”.

  5. Vladislav Zarayskiy Says:

    Dumitru, Moldovo-European war is very funny idea. Two-three days of medium intensity bombing (not like Serbia 10 years ago) will throw our country to Stone Age level. So let’s not discuss fantasies.

    As for looters – whoever brought them to streets did have political ideas and was worried about fraudulent elections. However, you need to realize that if you’re bringing soldiers who shout “Konstantin and Konstitutsiya”, assuming that Konstitutsiya is Konstantin’s wife (Decemberists rebellion of 1825) – you won’t succeed in your political plans. Same is true here – no matter how fraudulent elections were, this was overshadowed immediately by Romanian flags, Noi sintem romani for many people.
    But even those who don’t care about Moldovan political nuances soon saw that besides peaceful protesters “anti-Communists” also have regular looters.
    Hey, Maidan was just 4 years ago and it was much colder in Kiev but people were standing for days preventing all provocations (and Kiev is much larger). here, in nice warm weather nobody could organize a peaceful protest for a week but on the second day stormed and looted the parliament?
    Unfortunately, those youngsters weren’t protesting against elections – too many of them didn’t care about any politics. But why those people were let to use political slogans of legitimate opposition and no single opposition leader stood in front of the mob (at the single entrance of the Parliament) and told them to back down (even Yuschenko did it in 2004 at one moment) – that is another question.

    I’m not blaming anyone and not saying who was behind it. Though I’m sure that considering the experience of color revolutions of past decade, every Eastern European political party, even a ruling one, entertains the idea of such protests and have specific plans for that – so it might be that there were simultaneously Rosku, Voronin, Smirnov, Putin, and, say, Gimpu provocateurs in the mob. And some of them, even may receive salary from two and more people named above :-) We’ll see who will use this situation the best in coming months.

  6. Vladislav Zarayskiy Says:

    And yes, the first comment from Vlad (Chisinau-Boston) was also mine – forgot to properly log in. Sorry.

  7. Dumitru Minzarari Says:

    @ Vladislav
    Come on Vlad, you got my idea perfectly, I’d assume, stop twisting it – I meant a Russian-European war, where Moldova is back under the Russian control, whatever form this would take (a professor from the Russian MFA Diplomatic Academy was recently making prediction that the Soviet Union will be restored by 2012, as some kind of Eurasian Union, with Putin in rule). Sounds funny…
    I believe we have to be more careful, judging the Romanian flags that the young people were carrying. The current leadership was so obviously obstructing Moldova’s EU integration, that they, in their youth naivete, have though that only with Romania we are able to become a EU member. Can’t blame them – why PCRM hasn’t built during the 8 years some pride among the citizens with their country, and confidence that we can join EU by our own?

    Looters… talk to a psychologist (or polit-technologist) about the crowd effect… it is so easy to provoke a group of angry, especially young and with deep feeling of being betrayed people, to get violent. See my other posts on who possible was the instigator.. and think about the Latin (who has the interest in that) :)

  8. Vladislav Zarayskiy Says:

    Dumitru,
    you won’t believe but I spent the whole morning drive today (half an hour, give or take) contemplating any scenario in which you could see Moldovans creating problems for Europe. I thought of organized crime (no, can’t be, Albanians, urks and Arabs won’t let us in), wave of immigration (no, too small population), revolution hotspot (no, too easy to isolate in the corner). And all this time you were talking about Russian-European War. Sorry, I missed your point (pun intended).

    C’mon! If such war will take place, we don’t need to worry – just find a white bed sheet and crawl to the nearest cemetery. There won’t be any soldiers coming to Europe – only missiles from both sides (Anglo-Franco-American nuclear arsenal vs. Russian). Qucik and decisive exclamation point in the history of humankind. So I don’t believe in such scenario (neither I believe anymore in Eurasian Union) – it is more plausible than Moldovo-European war but still unrealistic. And, even if it was realistic, once again – severak days of bombing and that’s it. Moldova is not Siberia, it would be hit first (on the other hand, in Russian-Chinese war we could be the last to fall under Beijing rule, think from this perspective! :-) )

    As for pride and confidence… Unfortunately, it’s not only the fault of the government (though in rich countries it is easier to be patriotic than in poor ones) but also of intellectual elite. We must admit that independent Moldova is a phenomenon: we were the only republic of USSR that didn’t have independentist movement – we just had two groups of unionists: Romanian and Russian. In situation like that when nobody in elite is really pledging allegiance to their newly formed country, it is hard to inspire such allegiance among common people. So it’s the fault of not only PCRM but also (and I would blame them, probably, even more) Rosku with friends and, more recently, liberals.

    You can’t proudly live in the country about which everyone asks (even here, those rare Americans who know where Moldova is!) “So, when you’ll be part of Romania?” I’d really prefer to call myself and my friends “Basarabians” rather than “Russian-speaking Moldovan citizen” in contrast to my friends who are “Romanian-speaking Moldovan citizens”. Do you see my point?

    As for the interests and instigators – as I said, everyone had plans for such an event (unless they are idiots, and I don’t assume that) so everyone had some interest in it. You prefer to point all fingers to the east and then to the further east (and then you stop, realizing that China doesn’t care :-) ). But my position: if not taking into account, criminal justice, it is irrelevant now (and became quickly irrelevant yesterday around evening time when the looting didn’t spread further) who was the instigator(s). What is most important: who will gain the most – and that we’ll see.

    I think we should switch to emails – those comments are too lengthy for WordPress. What do you think?

  9. Dumitru Minzarari Says:

    @ Vladislav There was a cold war, during which USSR fought in real battles the West, but they did not bomb each other – the proxy wars. Cold War actually is my favorite example, and an amazing period to study and research – there are so many similarities with current events.

    Regarding what you named “independent Moldova phenomena” – that is just your idea and understanding… your personal theory. Things are rather different if you look at them carefully. I can go case by case, and country by country, and show you that basically all USSR republics had similarities to the point you stressed (two different groups), and that Moldova is not a worse case scenario. That’s is an academic debate topic, as it requires knowledge of the area, and theory on identity, sovietology, regionalism, etc.

    I’m anytime ready to communicate through e-mail, less these days for obvious reasons – it’s too hectic in Chisinau.

  10. Global Voices Online » Moldova: A Review of Blog Coverage Says:

    [...] “Orphans’ Revolution” – by Dumitru Minzarari: […] Now the communists and their Eastern “partners” are [...]

  11. blog » Blog Archive » idei limpezi in vremuri tulburi - 3 Says:

    [...] fără control – o sinteză oarecumc rudă, dar veridică a „Revoluţiei Moldoveneşti 1.0″. O revoluţie a orfanilor, ca să-l citez pe Dumitru [...]

  12. The “orphan Revolution” « Mudlark Tales Says:

    [...] have some called it an orphan revolution? Because under the current communist regime over a third of Moldovan [...]

  13. Moldova: Bloggers Cover News Corporate Media Ignores « Can’t hear this, you are in Audio Prison … Check what you listening to. Says:

    [...] “Orphans’ Revolution” – by Dumitru Minzarari: […] Now the communists and their Eastern “partners” are building a [...]


Leave a Reply